Issue 005
Target or limit: the Big Ten's new roster ceiling
The Big Ten capped school-arranged NIL deals at $27.5M a school, about $49M with revenue share. At the top it limits how you build. Lower down, it's a target.
On 28 October, the Big Ten's presidents and chancellors voted unanimously to cap how much each school can arrange in third-party NIL deals for its athletes: $27.5 million per school, effective immediately, with escalating financial penalties for violations. Add the revenue a school can share directly with its athletes under the House settlement, $21.3 million this year, and the total comes to about $49 million per school.
The conference said it wants schools to "plan, budget and build their rosters" under the Protect College Sports Act, which passed the Senate 77–22 but looks unlikely to clear the lame-duck House, according to Front Office Sports. The settlement's plaintiffs' lawyers say they'll fight the rule; lead attorney Steve Berman called it "a step in the wrong direction."
So the number is set. Whether it's a target or a limit depends on where you sit.
What's actually going on
The conference is trying to get ahead of the curve and become the precedent that legislation settles on. This is the Big Ten's version of a salary cap, built to create some parity so that competing for the top of the conference isn't reserved for the biggest spenders building super rosters.
The Big Ten is the richest conference in college sports: it distributed an average of $76.1 million per school for the 2024-25 fiscal year, ahead of the SEC's $72.4 million, according to CBS Sports. That gives the top tier room to spend up to the limit, and some already spend at or above it. CBS Sports reports that Ohio State and Oregon each spend more than $40 million on football alone this year.
Part of the line is fixed: the revenue share, which by all accounts every Big Ten school is paying up to.
The new rule covers only what a school arranges; athletes can still sign NIL deals with anyone on their own. What a department still controls is how it deploys capital, and how it drives the revenue to sustain it.
One number, two different problems
For the athletic director at the top of the conference, the ceiling becomes a limit on how he builds a roster. It changes how those programs negotiate with players. I'd expect the arms race of the last few years to cool and roster building to get more strategic.
For the athletic director or GM at the bottom, the same number is a target, and the limiting factor is their own resources. Across Division I, only 68 of the 319 schools that opted into revenue sharing reached the $20.5 million cap in its first year, or came within 5% of it, according to College Sports Commission filings reported by the AP. The new line sits at more than twice that cap.
One part of that could work in the lower tier's favor. The cap may force the hand of the upper-echelon schools: individual deals shrink, and more talent leaves those programs than in past years.
The pros have run this play before
When the NFL opened up free agency in 1993, it paired it with a salary cap, starting in 1994, to protect competitive balance for smaller markets. The first big free agent of the new system, Reggie White, signed with Green Bay, the league's smallest market. Green Bay and Kansas City have both won Super Bowls in the cap era.
Later, the ceiling got a floor. The 2011 collective bargaining agreement required every team to spend at least 89% of the cap in cash over four-year periods, and a team that falls short pays the difference directly to its players. A team could no longer sit well under the line and keep the savings.
The NBA went after how the top builds, not just how much it spends. Its 2023 agreement added a second apron, a payroll line well above the cap. Teams over it can't combine salaries in trades, take back more salary than they send out, or use the exceptions that let teams sign free agents over the cap. In 2025, a year after winning the title, Boston traded Jrue Holiday and Kristaps Porziņģis within a day to cut payroll. "The second apron is why those trades happened," Celtics president Brad Stevens said.
Baseball shows the alternative. MLB has no salary cap, only a tax on payroll above a threshold. The Dodgers paid a record $169.4 million in tax for 2025, on top of their payroll, and won their second straight World Series. Their tax bill alone was bigger than the payrolls of 12 teams.
The Big Ten's rule caps what schools arrange, leaves athletes' own deals open and sets no floor. It limits the top without asking anything of the bottom. Whether it plays like the NFL's hard cap or baseball's tax line depends on how much money finds its way around it.
Building toward a number you can't fund yet
I've seen this from the under-resourced side, in health care. I spent almost three years as managing director of a regional health system's center for innovation. We didn't have the same resources as some of the neighboring research hospitals. So we took a community-driven approach. We set out to capture the entrepreneurial spirit that already existed inside the system and use it to drive innovation.
We built commercial pathways for newly developed IP. We supported in-house entrepreneurs with consulting and access to ecosystem resources. We brought outside IP into the ecosystem, all toward the quadruple aim: better care, healthier communities, lower costs and a better working life for clinicians.
Schools at the lower end of the conference's commercial scale will need their own version of that to stay competitive.
Anyone who has run an under-resourced organization knows the internal conflict.
You understand it takes money to make money: you have to invest in talent and capacity to elevate the organization. But finding the initial capital to get the plan built and started, knowing the results aren't guaranteed, is where the friction comes in.
It’s hard to uncover and earmark resources to invest in tomorrow when today's bottom line still isn't certain.
So you compete on a different plane. You find your own blue ocean inside the red ocean of competition, and the target stays the destination: more a stretch goal than an annual one. More often than not, the money gap starts as a capability gap.
What the programs that make it work do differently
The commercially established schools will find ways around a hard-dollar cap, as they always do, with perks and benefits of equivalent value that aren't cash.
Whatever their tier, the programs that make a cap like this work will lock in multi-year agreements with players. Multi-year revenue-share contracts are permitted, and most departments still aren't using them.
The programs still building their commercial engine will have to get more entrepreneurial: in how they create revenue, in the outside revenue streams they build, and in the businesses and organizations they partner with to create new ones. They'll balance roster stability with partnership activation and expansion.
One athletic director who has caught my eye is Syracuse's Bryan Blair. Syracuse plays in the ACC, but it faces the same math. Blair took over this summer describing the job as building a modern athletics enterprise that generates more revenue.
In October, Syracuse signed New Era as official headwear provider for all 20 programs, with an expanded licensed line and annual NIL deals for its athletes. Days later came a seven-year partnership making Upstate Medical University its exclusive healthcare partner and sponsor.
It can be done from below the line. Indiana won the national championship in January, and Curt Cignetti told On3 that the roster's final cost was "closer to $15 million than $40 million."
Where it goes
My read: this rule spends a year or two in the balance before federal legislation overtakes it. It may not be this bill. But this won't be the last proposal, and at some point one of them will land that makes commercial viability a mandate.
Three to five years out, the better-positioned departments will be the ones that took an entrepreneurial approach first. Every institution has assets it hasn't fully activated: brand, intellectual property, content and media. The groups that treat these proposals as a reason to run the institution differently will move away from the donor-based model and toward a commercial enterprise that can shift with the legislation.
Knowing your number
The departments that come through moments like this well tend to start with an honest read of where they stand: their resources, their brand recognition and value, and their commercial position relative to the rest of the conference. That read is what tells them whether $49 million is their number, or whether the smarter path is building toward one of their own.
The athletic directors who move with that kind of clarity, with a North Star of becoming a more commercially anchored enterprise, will be ready for whichever proposal lands.
—MC
